Tuesday, 10 April 2012

Dragon Age: Origins

I haven't played many of the Bioware games (Only Mass Effect and Dragon Age: Origins) but I'm noticing a strange formula. The exposition of the game is straightforward and eases you in, perhaps followed by more of a challenge to keep you on your toes; But then the world opens up, you arrive at a new location getting six shades of shit beaten out of you by some brutes and wondering whether you managed to spectacularly fuck up somewhere. As said, this is just my own observation; perhaps I am seeing something others aren't like a cat on psychedelics. This theory could be a result of my usual response that if I'm not enjoying something it's somehow my fault and I have approached the thing from some unexpected angle or misinterpreted it like a slack jawed Luddite clawing fruitlessly at a supermarket self service booth.

While playing this game I've battled with this psychological hiccup of mine trying to determine whether this game is indeed a wondrous creation to be championed as many others have, or something which seeks to punish me for having the audacity to try and enjoy it.
I sought to find other people who shared my opinions via the interwebs and found some fellow fiends who retracted as violently as I did from time to time during gameplay. In true internet tradition, I decided to write my own personal observations since surely no one gives two fucks about them.. or maybe there is someone, lurking on the shadow underbelly of the American dream waiting to congratulate me for voicing an opinion they can relate to.

As you undoubtedly know, Dragon Age: Origins is an RPG from Bioware (Creators of Mass effect and Knights of the old republic) which has been hailed as some kind of marvellous role playing extravaganza which engrossed and entertained many a nerd and achieved enough accolade to sprout a sequel. I bought this game after completing Mass Effect which I enjoyed to quite a substantial degree (despite my usual unreasonable standards), and decided to try another one of Bioware's offspring for size.



The story concept is relatively interesting: involving political betrayal, a demonic invasion and such which serves the purpose rather nicely but didn't do enough to really pull me in and offer an environment where I truly want to know as much of the situation as possible.
The dialogue is pretty well presented and voice acted with few occasions where the actors ham it up (which is a colossal bugbear of mine).
It can be at least said that I understood what my goal was and why I was tasked to accomplish it which shouldn't be much of a talking point, however an alarming number of games in this day and age hardly provide a sense of importance or context for the player's actions at all.

The first issue I encountered was the nature of the party AI. You are able to control each member of your party individually during combat, choosing attacks and taking potions etc but aside from the straightforward skirmishes, the battles typically descend into a monumental cluster fuck.
Your entire party far too often requires complex micromanagement in order to even stand a chance at achieving victory, the result of this being that the whole experience becomes about as immersive as watching porn through a neighbours window.

The aforementioned not withstanding the difficulty curve also seems to go up and down like a whore's thighs, creating an incredibly frustrating number of instances where the task at hand appears little other than impossible. A phrase I coined in some brutish swirling torrent of swearing and desk thrashing was, 'Why have 5 enemies, when we could have 10?'.
As previously mentioned the fights typically transform into a freelance cluster fuck with all tactics becoming truly redundant, causing you to switch between characters like an indecisive girl picking a dress for a night out.

An example of excessive enemy quantities includes one dungeon where I was challenged with two stone golems to battle simultaneously which provided an ample challenge; however, only one room later I was put against at least six of them and a warrior boss. Such an instance demonstrates that the rise in difficulty is not reasonably exponential, in the space of two rooms how exactly could I have improved my performance to deal with three times the previous challenge?

During my campaign I used Wynn in my party as a dedicated healer, since potions were puzzlingly difficult to obtain and about as effective as a cat flap in an elephant house. Even with this wrinkly old bat in my party, I struggled to get anywhere in battles and wondered with some concern how anyone would be able to accomplish these feats without the withered old prune. My party was relatively balanced too with myself as the dual wielding rogue, Alistair as the warrior 'Tank', Morrigan throwing some magic and Wynn as healer, but I was struggling greatly to deal with the most primary of tasks in this game.

When travelling between locations the horrid ghoul of 'random encounters' pops its ugly head from time to time. I feared these engagements veritably and cursed the gods when one cropped up since often these fights possessed a difficulty almost rivalling boss fights. It's somewhat unsettling when you have become the Champion of Redcliffe, slayer of a 1000 Darkspawn and saviour of the people only to be brutally savaged by a pack of wolves when walking to the local town. It doesn't help either that creatures such as wolves and spiders also have a skill where they overwhelm you and perform a violent flurry of attacks, during which you are as vulnerable as a stray cupcake in the company of a particularly fat bastard.

On the subject of creatures, these are distributed time to time with some truly arbitrary logic. I was in the woods pursuing werewolves for the Dalish Elf tribe (which was actually a very entertaining quest) and followed the hairy brutes into a series of underground ruins (which were apparently their home), only to become engaged by skeletons and spiders. 'Skeletons and spiders..' I thought, why in the name of Lucifer's lawnmower are skeletons and fucking spiders scooting their boots around a werewolf lair?! why the hell would they have any truce with these fiends? and why would the werewolves pick to base their entire operation from the basement of this foul domain.
Dragon age appears as a fairly redundant title, maybe they should have taken a page from dungeons and dragons and opted for 'Spiders and Skeletons' for the number of times they appear in this game. Perhaps with the additional suffix of 'Why have five skeletons (and/or) spiders when we could have ten'.
I like to entertain the notion that this was performed in order to keep a moody modeller happy who wanted to see his eight legged and bony creations championed in all three glorious dimensions at every opportunity. I can practically say with certainty this was the case for whoever made those fucking fire traps that lay upon every walk way of the entire kingdom. I shit you not, the one room had a fire trap every 5 metres along it's entire length for a good 30 metres or so; there was more fire in that fucking room than the Devil's basement.



The approval system involving distributing gifts to party members to increase their approval wasn't so hot; The motive for this is that at a high approval they unlock some skills and don't attempt to leave the party. Surely this is a flawed philosophy, how exactly will giving someone a present distract them from the fact that you just threatened to murder a priest if they didn't free a convicted murderer; Perhaps these are reincarnated magpies we are dealing with. Some of the gifts which are apparently respective to individual characters don't often operate as expected either, I accidentally gave Alistair a bone intended for the dog but he was over the fucking moon with it.

I've read responses the the criticism of this game regarding difficulty stating that you should leave the area you're having trouble with and level up through side quests. I considered this option in game, but the only quest which could be performed prior to finishing the story objectives climaxed with a desk smashingly tough room full of bandits including several mages, against whom you may as well just roll the fucking credits for the most part. A couple of errand quests existed but these were pretty arbitrary, including tasks such as retrieving 15 venom vials or finding letters which were scattered all over the kingdom. One might propose seeking out the random encounters to raise experience via combat but this boils down to grinding which is something to be loathed; especially in a single player game. I didn't buy an RPG game to spend most of my time in it mindlessly slaughtering the local wildlife in order to be capable of the story quests.

I found myself, perhaps like many others comparing this game to Mass effect. I felt that Mass effect (AI stupidity aside) was at least able to operate in combat situations without putting me in the position of a fucking babysitter where I am responsible for my entire party, preventing me from getting into my own character and exploring their potential. At the end of the day after all, this is a 'Role playing game' and if I am unable to play my proverbial role without dropping into others every twenty seconds to guzzle a potion, or remind a fellow party member to punch a skeleton in the back of the head then something is wrong with the formula.

The tag line for this game is 'A dark fantasy in a unique world' but I call this into question. How exactly is this world unique? The races are the standard issue Tolkien affair with Axe wielding bearded Dwarves, Bow totting wood elves and the humans on the soapbox being ignorant and discreetly racist. The Dark prefix doesn't hold much weight either, there's quite a lot of blood thrown around and a little foul language but that's about the extent of it. Surely a 'Dark' game would seek to emphasize the more insalubrious aspects of the world in order to provide an more blinkered atmosphere. I don't mention this because I feel that this is what is missing from the game, however if they were attempting something 'dark' then I consider it unsuccessful.

I don't care for mentioning Graphics to any substantial degree here because I couldn't give a shit provided I can understand what the object is via it's visual representation, this said I will state that I thought the console version looked a bit muddy. I played it on the PC since I recently scraped the pennies together to afford to upgrade my system and wanted to justify it, not because I am somehow hideously biased towards consoles.

Perhaps through this carnival of criticism I have given the impression I hate this game, which I do not; I liked the game but I didn't feel as though it liked me back. The difficulty of the game consisted of jagged peaks rather than a nice incremental curve which left me flinching while I was enjoying the game anticipating another beating. The whole thing is nicely presented, story and such included; but it frequently failed to enthral me and provide challenges which I could enjoy rather than lament. I had no intention when playing this game other than to enjoy it, no clandestine agenda like a console fanboy who plays a game on another system to try and give the illusion of neutrality, only to inevitably verbally soil it as though it violated his sister.

To summarize, I hope that I'm not alone in saying that Dragon Age: Origins missed the mark for me in terms of creating an entertaining experience. This being a result of the bloated micro management excess and other such issues. The difficulty curve wasn't a challenge which could be enjoyed and approached with intrigue, further tainting a perfectly decent game experience. I hope RPGs will emerge more frequently which pertain to some fantasy tales which don't walk the path of predecessors so closely, there is no law for fantasy; the title itself encompasses freedom of creation. Go nuts... maybe omit the dwarves and elves, or at least give an elf a beard or something.

No comments:

Post a Comment